Menu
NewsLive stream - European Holocaust Research Infrastructure Academic Conference European Holocaust Research Infrastructure Academic Conference
Invitation to submit proposals to the >Materials #StandWithAlex We mourn Nechama Tec
We mourn with sadness Prof. Nechama Tec, who was with the Center for many years. A member of the Scientific Council of the annual "Holocaust Studies and Materials".
add your e-mail to the
NEWSLETTER |
Zagłada Żydów.
PAMIĘTNIK
Zagłada Żydów.
NIE WIEMY CO PRZYNIESIE NAM KOLEJNA GODZINA ...
Zagłada Żydów.
Aryjskiego Żyda wspomnienia, łzy i myśli Sewek Okonowski, oprac. Marta Janczewska
PISZĄCY TE SŁOWA JEST PRACOWNIKIEM
CZYTAJĄC GAZETĘ NIEMIECKĄ ...
Zagłada Żydów.
Zagłada Żydów.
ŻADNA BLAGA, ŻADNE KŁAMSTWO ...
Zagłada Żydów.
TYLEŚMY JUŻ PRZESZLI ...
WŚRÓD ZATRUTYCH NOŻY ...
PO WOJNIE, Z POMOCĄ BOŻĄ, JUŻ NIEBAWEM ...
Zagłada Żydów.
SNY CHOCIAŻ MAMY WSPANIAŁE ...
Zagłada Żydów.
Mietek Pachter
Zagłada Żydów.
OCALONY Z ZAGŁADY
ZAGŁADA ŻYDÓW. STUDIA I MATERIAŁY
... TĘSKNOTA NACHODZI NAS JAK CIĘŻKA CHOROBA ...
Raul Hilberg
Monika Polit
Dariusz Libionka i Laurence Weinbaum
Zagłada Żydów.
Jan Grabowski
Stanisław Gombiński (Jan Mawult)
Holocaust Studies and Materials
Żydów łamiących prawo należy karać śmiercią!
Zagłada Żydów.
Wybór źródeł do nauczania o zagładzie Żydów
W Imię Boże!
Zagłada Żydów.
Żydzi w powstańczej Warszawie
Reportaże z warszawskiego getta
Notatnik
Holocaust
Źródła do badań nad zagładą Żydów na okupowanych ziemiach polskich
Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały
Prowincja noc.
Utajone miasto.
Sprawcy, Ofiary, Świadkowie.
Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały
"Jestem Żydem, chcę wejść!".
Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały
'Ja tego Żyda znam!'
'Szanowny panie Gistapo!'
aaa
Zagłada Żydów.
PAMIĘTNIK
Zagłada Żydów.
NIE WIEMY CO PRZYNIESIE NAM KOLEJNA GODZINA ...
Zagłada Żydów.
Aryjskiego Żyda wspomnienia, łzy i myśli Sewek Okonowski, oprac. Marta Janczewska
PISZĄCY TE SŁOWA JEST PRACOWNIKIEM
CZYTAJĄC GAZETĘ NIEMIECKĄ ...
Zagłada Żydów.
Zagłada Żydów.
ŻADNA BLAGA, ŻADNE KŁAMSTWO ...
Zagłada Żydów.
TYLEŚMY JUŻ PRZESZLI ...
WŚRÓD ZATRUTYCH NOŻY ...
PO WOJNIE, Z POMOCĄ BOŻĄ, JUŻ NIEBAWEM ...
Zagłada Żydów.
SNY CHOCIAŻ MAMY WSPANIAŁE ...
Zagłada Żydów.
Mietek Pachter
Zagłada Żydów.
OCALONY Z ZAGŁADY
ZAGŁADA ŻYDÓW. STUDIA I MATERIAŁY
... TĘSKNOTA NACHODZI NAS JAK CIĘŻKA CHOROBA ...
Raul Hilberg
Monika Polit
Dariusz Libionka i Laurence Weinbaum
Zagłada Żydów.
Jan Grabowski
Stanisław Gombiński (Jan Mawult)
Holocaust Studies and Materials
Żydów łamiących prawo należy karać śmiercią!
Zagłada Żydów.
Wybór źródeł do nauczania o zagładzie Żydów
W Imię Boże!
Zagłada Żydów.
Żydzi w powstańczej Warszawie
Reportaże z warszawskiego getta
Notatnik
Holocaust
Źródła do badań nad zagładą Żydów na okupowanych ziemiach polskich
Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały
Prowincja noc.
Utajone miasto.
Sprawcy, Ofiary, Świadkowie.
Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały
"Jestem Żydem, chcę wejść!".
Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały
'Ja tego Żyda znam!'
'Szanowny panie Gistapo!'
aaa
Polish Center for Holocaust Research
Nowy Swiat St. 72, 00-330 Warsaw; POLAND; Palac Staszica room 120 e-mail: centrum@holocaustresearch.pl Review of Timothy Snyder's, Black Earth by Jan GrabowskiReview of Timothy Snyder's, Black Earth by Jan Grabowski07.03.2016 14:49:45
Jan Grabowski Unlike the studies written by Raul Hilberg, Christoper Browning, Saul Friedlander, Peter Longerich and Martin Gilbert, “Black Earth” is rather a flowing, meandering, historical essay where one would look in vain for an exhaustive discussion of the Holocaust. The book opens with a brief presentation of Hitler’s world view, his obsession with the “world Jewish conspiracy” and the resultant need for a Lebensraum for the German master-race. The struggle for the “living space” (located in the half-mythical “East”) was to erupt in a direct confrontation - as Hitler thought - with the “world Jewry and its lackeys”; foremost among them- the Soviet Union. The following chapters discuss at length the place of the “Jewish question” on the pre-war international diplomatic stage, with particular stress placed on the policies of the Polish Foreign Office. The most important - and most coherent - part of the book deals with the Nazi doctrine of “state destruction” as a necessary means to achieve the goal of total domination of Germanic race on the European (and later, presumably, on the world) stage. The description of the destruction of the states begins with Austria, followed by Czechoslovakia through Poland and - after the attack on the Soviet Union - extends to the rest of the Slavic East, and the Baltic countries. The destruction of the states went hand in hand - Snyder argues - with the destruction of the Jews. And the degree of efficiency of the German plans of extermination was directly linked to the degree of destruction of the structures of the conquered states. It is precisely in these areas that the American historian begins his discussion of “double state destruction” and “double occupation” - referring to the eastern parts of the II Polish Republic as well as to Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia which first found themselves under the Soviet occupation and later, in the summer of 1941, were occupied by the Germans. In these areas former communists and the agents of the Soviet terror apparatus of yesterday, eagerly embraced the German policies of extermination. “As in the doubly-occupied lands, in the pre-war Soviet Union Jews were sacrificed” - writes Snyder - “ for the holy lie of the collective innocence of others” (181). In other words, it was not the local Belorussians, Poles, Ukrainians or Lithuanians who had to pay for their previous collaboration with the Soviets, but the Jews. The killing of the Jews was, therefore, instrumental on various levels: it allowed the locals to avoid responsibility for the recent past, it enabled them to curry favor with the new German masters and, last but definitely not least, it sealed and finalized the earlier theft of Jewish property. The term “double destruction of the state” allows Snyder to discuss at length the mass murder of the Jewish populations at the hands of the Einsatzgruppen, the police and their local helpers. This part of the Shoah, is known in the Western historiography as “Holocaust by bullets” - a term introduced by Patrick Desbois, to whom, surprisingly, Snyder, makes no reference. The author stresses that mass shootings which took place behind at the rear of the advancing German armies, claimed over one million victims; that the executions were happening in public and made hundreds of thousands German soldiers (and their families) aware of and complicit in the Nazi policies of extermination. The subsequent chapters trace the different reasons which influenced people and institutions which helped (or refused to help) the Jewish refugees at the time of need. The final chapter entitled “Our World” makes an attempt to look at the dangers facing humanity today and seeks lessons from the Shoah. “Black Earth’s” Leitmotiv can be summarized in a few words: “State exists - Jews live; state is gone - Jews perish”. In the areas where the Germans succeeded in destroying the preexistent state structures, the fate of the Jews - argues Snyder - was incomparably worse than that of the Jews living in the still-preserved states. According to Snyder: “Throughout Europe, but to a different degrees in different places, German occupation destroyed the institutions that made ideas of reciprocity seem plausible. Where Germans obliterated conventional states, or annihilated Soviet institutions that had just destroyed conventional states, they created the abyss where racism and politics pulled together towards nothingness”. (p. 319-320). The expression “destruction of the state” returns in Snyder’s book with troubling frequency - as if to allow even the least perceptive reader to grasp the true message of the book. There are pages on which the expression “destroyed states” (in various forms) appears four, five, or more times! It can be argued that an important argument needs to be restated from time to time, but one can hardly expect to see it repeated a few hundred times! Instead of the nebulous “state destruction” one could simply say that the Germans, wherever they could, introduced a system of governance based on an unprecedented level of terror. And they could do it in these parts of Europe where it was possible to safely disregard the local and the world public opinion, in the areas inhabited by peoples who found themselves at he lowest rungs of the Nazi ladder of “racial respectability”. In other words - in the Slavic east, in Poland and on the territories east of Poland, where the vast majority of Europe’s Jews lived. But such a thesis would, of course, be hardly original, and hence the awkward and relentlessly repeated concept of “destroyed states” served as a founding idea, which provides “Black Earth” with its raison d’être. The “destruction of the states” - according to Snyder - was something unprecedented, it was a radical step which transformed human attitudes. Even if true, is it enough to offer a convincing explanation for the reasons of the destruction of the European Jewry? To put it in simple terms, the level of terror instituted in the public sphere by the Germans provides much more convincing argument than the abstract notion of ”destroyed state” Occupied Poland, known at the time as the Generalgouvernement (GG), is a case in point. True, at the end of 1943 and in early 1944 the situation in the Generalgouvernement evolved towards anarchy but, in the spring, summer and fall of 1942, when Germans emptied the ghettos and deported 1.5 million Polish Jews to extermination camps, occupied Poland was far from being a disorganized, stateless entity. Despite the terror and violence (which should not be mistaken with the abstract notion of “destroyed state”), workers toiled in factories, doctors saw patients, people paid taxes and rents, police regulated traffic, courts heard criminal and civil cases, and theatres were packed full with move-goers. What was then the influence of the “destruction of the state” on the fate of the Jews? The abstract notion of “destroyed state” cannot accunt for the success of the German genocidal project. The level of terror combined with popular complicity based on pre-war and war-time antisemitism can, however, offer a more convincing explanation. It is within this context that Snyder claims that the populations living in the “zones of the double-destruction of the state” and in the conquered parts of the Soviet Union were most likely to take part in the implementation of German policies of extermination. In contrast “In occupied Poland, the Holocaust began more than two years after the German invasion and was largely isolated from the local population. In the occupied Soviet Union, the killing of Jews took place in the open air, in front of the population, with the help of young male Soviet citizens” (150). Snyder is wrong. The few closed ghettos (such as Warsaw or Cracow) were exceptions - and even in these cases the contacts with the “Aryan” side were frequent and multiple. The majority of Polish Jews, however, were removed into half-open or open ghettos where the only real physical barrier separating them from the “Aryan side”consisted of wooden fences or barbed wire, both easily breached. The real borders of the ghettos were in the minds of the gentiles, who enforced (with great efficiency) and helped to enforce the restrictions placed by the Germans on Jews. To makes Snyder’s assertion even more implausible, hundreds of thousands of Polish Jews were resettled into the ghettos only in the spring and in the summer of 1942, on the eve of the implementation of the final solution. For these reasons there can be no question about the isolation of the Jews from the rest of the society. What is more important, the liquidations of hundreds of ghettos across Poland (Germans referred to them as “Aktionen”) occurred in the midst of Polish towns and cities and millions of Poles witnessed the destruction of Jewish communities. The Aktionen became scenes of unprecedented and hitherto unknown violence during which the streets of Polish cities, quite literally, run with blood. The local population has only been witnessing these events, but many became directly involved in German genocidal plans, and contributed to the deaths of their Jewish neighbors. Untold thousands of “bystanders” accompanied Jews on their last trip to the death trains, thousands more took part in the feverish searches of the recently emptied ghettos, stealing the Jewish property and pulling the hidden Jews out of their hideouts and bunkers. The “bystanders” worked hand in hand with the “blue” policemen, the firefighters and the yunaks from the Construction Service (Baudienst). Even a hasty overview of the Jewish testimonies from places such as Tarnów, Działoszyce, Miechów, Dąbrowa, Szczebrzeszyn, Węgrów, Stoczek, Sokołów, Siedlce,to name but a few, provides ample and undeniable proof that the Holocaust in Poland was definitely not “isolated from the local population” - as claimed by the author of “Black Earth”. While one can agree with Snyder that too much focus on Auschwitz can lead to an opaque, myopic and flawed perception of the Shoah, the quasi-complete absence of any substantial discussion of Aktion Reinhardt in his own book is hard to explain and even more difficult to accept. As it is, the extermination camps in Beżłec, Majdanek, Sobibór and Treblinka (sites where 1.5 million Jews have been put to death) have, for all practical purposes, been removed from Snyder’s account. Readers of “Black Earth” would look in vain for any substantial discussion of Treblinka- a place where nearly one million have been killed. The name “Treblinka” is being mentioned in the book eight times but practically all of these references are peripheral to the issue and carry little, or no informative value. Can one write about the Holocaust (especially in the context of the occupied East) and leave out Treblinka? Incidentally, the extermination camps in Bełżec and Sobibór, sites of respectively 500.000 and 150.000 Jewish deaths, are treated in the book with an even greater insoucience than Treblinka and are hardly mentioned at all. Can one write about the Holocaust in the East and leave out these “primitive, but efficient production lines of death” - as described by SS-Untersturmführer Franz Suchomel in his interview with Claude Lanzmann? Similar reservations about the coherence and structure of the text come to mind while reading the closing chapters of the book which touch upon the issue of rescue of Jews in the Holocaust. In this case, Snyder calls upon many Jewish testimonies from collection 301 of the Jewish Historical Institute in Warsaw, interviews with survivors from the databases of the US Holocaust Museum in Washington and from the YIVO archives. These testimonies are fascinating and, as the scholars of the Holocaust know well, they are among the most touching and moving documents of the period. And the choice is rich: in Warsaw alone there are seven thousand of these “early testimonies”, collected from Jewish survivors, during the 1944-47 period, by the local Jewish Committees. It is altogether unclear, however, what were the selection criteria which guided the author of “Black Earth” in his choices. Although from time to time the author draws our attention to the impact of the “state destruction” upon the fate of the quoted Jewish witnesses, it seems as if the testimonies found their way to the book (just as did Drymmer and the Polish Foreign Office) more by accident then by design. The last chapter (“Conclusion: Our World”) is moralistic and prophetic, and carries a warning for humanity. According to Snyder, Hitler’s vision of the world was inherently linked to the destruction of European Jewry, seen as an impediment to the final triumph of the Germanic race. The removal of the Jews - argues Snyder - would allow the Germans to access the unlimited food supplies in the mythical East and enabled further strengthening of the Volksgemeinschaft. Now, in the second decade of the XXI century- writes the American historian - the world faces similar threats, although related to a different kind of danger: the global warming. “The expected increase of average global temperatures by four degrees Celsius this century would transform human life on much of the globe. Climate change” - pontificates the author of “Black Earth” - “is unpredictable”. “If ice sheets collapse, heat from the sun will be absorbed by seawater rather than reflected back into space. If the Siberian tundra melts, methane will rise from the earth...”. In the face of the approaching climatic Armageddon we should, warns Snyder, remember about the lessons of the Shoah. To quote once again from the final chapter of the book: “Perhaps the experience of unprecedented storms or relentless droughts will jar expectations about the security of basic resources and make Hitlerian politics more resonant”. Michael Marrus, one of the most eminent scholars of the Holocaust once observed: “...every historical event and every individual is unique, in that each is different from any other. Unlike social scientists, who search for generalities, historians are especially aware of such uniqueness, and indeed specialize in discerning those elements that make a particular event or society or individual unlike another. Normally, their focus is on the particular rather than the general. Historians study a revolution, rather than revolutions; a war, rather than warfare; and the Holocaust rather than genocide. Naturally, historians have their ideas about the latter, but they do not usually earn their living by such pronouncements, and I venture to say that these are not the most valued exercises of historical scholars’ time”. What Marrus refers to are not, of course, generalizations associated with historical research, but sweeping observations and hypotheses which have little or no rooting in the presented evidence and which have no obvious links to the discussed issues. One can only regret that Timothy Snyder failed to follow Michael Marrus’ wise advise. Originally in Polish, in: Zagłada Żydów. Studia i Materiały, vol. 11, Y. 2015, pp. 726-733 |